Pros and cons of having two dental insurance: Ultimate guide

Navigating the Maze of two Dental Insurance: A Comprehensive Guide

In the current healthcare environment, a lot of people have to manage several insurance plans, frequently combining employer-sponsored and privately acquired coverage. This complexity also applies to dental insurance, as some people may be covered by two different policies their own and their spouse’s or a combination of group and individual plans. With the potential for more comprehensive coverage and lower out-of-pocket expenses, having two dental insurance policies may sound like a good idea, but before choosing one, it’s important to thoroughly consider the advantages and disadvantages.

Understanding the Basics of two Dental Insurance

Having two current dental insurance policies at the same time is referred to as having two dental insurance, also known as secondary dental insurance. This situation usually occurs when a person is covered by their own job and additionally receives coverage as a dependant under the employer-sponsored plan of their spouse. As an alternative, some people might decide to add to their primary coverage by buying a supplemental dental insurance plan.

Pros and cons of having two dental insurance
Pros and cons of having two dental insurance

Pros of two Dental Insurance

  1. Better Coverage and Lower Out-of-Pocket Expenses: The possibility for improved coverage and lower out-of-pocket expenses is one of the main advantages of having two dental insurance policies. People may have access to a greater variety of covered treatments, higher maximum benefit limits, and reduced copayments or deductibles by combining the benefits of two plans. This can be especially helpful for people who need a lot of dental work done or have certain treatment requirements that their primary plan might not fully cover.
  2. Wider Provider Network: Having two dental insurance plans gives you access to a larger network of dental professionals. People who reside in places where there are few dental care options or who have particular preferences about the location, practise style, or area of specialisation of their dentist may find this to be extremely helpful.
  3. Protection Against Annual Maximums: The entire amount of coverage that a dental insurance plan will offer in a given year is represented by the annual maximum, which is a feature of many dental insurance plans. When two dental insurance plans are joined, the combined maximums from each can effectively raise the total amount of coverage offered. This could help people avoid prematurely meeting their annual limits and paying more out-of-pocket.
  4. Improved Benefits and Services: Having two dental insurance policies may allow you to have a higher maximum coverage limit, which will give you access to a wider range of dental services. A single insurance plan may not cover the full cost of many dental procedures, especially the more costly ones. When two plans are combined, there’s a greater likelihood that the total limits would cover the full range of dental procedures. You can choose from a greater range of dental procedures without being limited by the maximum benefit cap of a particular plan.
  5. Reduced Expenses Out of Pocket: The benefit of combined coverage—which can drastically lower the amount you have to pay out of pocket—comes when you have two dental insurance plans. Depending on its coverage guidelines and benefit coordination, the secondary insurance may pay all or part of the remaining amount after the primary plan has paid its portion. This can lessen your financial burden, especially for costly procedures where the primary insurance may not cover everything.
  6. Introduction of Secondary Coverage: After the primary insurance has paid its share, secondary insurance acts as an extra barrier. Having a backup plan can save your life if your primary plan does not cover all of your expenses. It can pay for any remaining costs that would otherwise have to be paid out of pocket. This supplementary insurance expands the financial safeguard against dental health costs.
  7. Expanded Provider Network: You may be able to access a larger network of dentists if you have two separate dental insurance policies. This may give you more options to choose from when it comes to dentists, as some may be in-network or preferred providers for certain plans but not for others. As a result, you not only have a fallback option in case one plan doesn’t cover a particular provider, but you also have the freedom to select a provider of your choice or one that is more convenient for you, which may improve the standard of your dental care.
  8. Major Dental Work and Preventive Care Coverage: By combining two dental insurance plans, a more complete level of coverage for major dental procedures and preventive care can be provided. If you’re thinking about getting major dental work done, like crowns, bridges, or orthodontics, the combined benefits from both insurances could help you out financially. In addition, even though premium costs for dual coverage can be comparable to out-of-pocket costs for preventive care services like cleanings, exams, and X-rays, these services are frequently covered at high percentages, adding value to the coverage.
  9. Long-Term Cost Savings: Although paying two premiums may seem like a bigger upfront expense, there may be significant long-term savings, especially if you eventually need extensive dental work. Because two insurance plans have higher coverage limits, they can help you save money on expensive dental procedures. After the primary insurance has been applied, the second dental insurance may be able to cover the remaining costs with careful benefit coordination, thereby lowering long-term out-of-pocket expenses.
  10. Benefits Coordination for Family Members: If two working parents provide dental insurance for the family, the coordination may result in more extensive dental coverage for the kids. This works together to provide better dental care and lower costs for their dependents’ necessary dental services by designating one parent’s plan as the primary insurance and the other as the secondary.
  11. Special Treatments and Elective Procedures: If you have two insurance plans, you may be able to get elective procedures that one of them might not cover, or might only cover in part. This is so that you can take advantage of treatments and specialized procedures that enhance not only your dental health but also your general wellbeing and confidence by having a second insurance to cover the gaps.
  12. Possibility of Better Care Quality: You are more likely to seek out preventive care and accept suggested treatments if your insurance is more comprehensive, which can enhance your general oral health. Improved financial coverage prevents patients from postponing required procedures out of fear of financial hardship, and this proactive measure can avert future dental problems that could be more costly and complex. As a result, this may lessen the need for emergency dental care, which is frequently more expensive and less successful over time.
  13. Financial Planning and Budgeting: Having two dental insurance plans can be a big part of a person’s financial planning, especially if they prioritize their oral health and are likely to need multiple procedures. When you combine the coverage from both plans with your own understanding of your maximum out-of-pocket costs, it makes budgeting for dental expenses more predictable.

Cons of two Dental Insurance

  1. Added Administrative Complexity: Handling two dental insurance policies can make the administration of healthcare more difficult. People might have to manage several deductibles, copayments, and claim submissions in addition to understanding the coordination of benefits (COB) regulations and coordinating benefits between two plans.
  2. Possibility of Overlapping Coverage: There is a chance that two dental insurance policies will overlap, which could result in needless premiums and administrative expenses. Carefully weighing the advantages of each plan is necessary to prevent duplication and make sure that the added value of the combined coverage outweighs the additional cost.
  3. Possibility of Higher Premiums: The total cost of dental coverage will always rise when a second dental insurance plan is added. Before making a choice, people should carefully assess their unique needs and financial status, balancing the potential advantages against the higher premiums.
  4. Complexity in Management: The way the two insurances interact is decided by the system of coordination of benefits, which can significantly increase the complexity of managing your dental care. A thorough examination of the fine print of both insurance policies is necessary to determine which is considered the primary one and when the secondary one will take effect. Having to manage two sets of policies, documentation, and claims processes makes things more complicated. This is particularly true when the plans have different benefits, copays, and covered services.
  5. Complicated Personal Documentation: Having two dental insurances means you have to be extremely careful with your claims, Explanation of Benefits (EOB) statements, and out-of-pocket costs. Maintaining personal records becomes increasingly important because losing or neglecting to track these records can cause issues with both insurance companies, impact claims in the future, or interfere with benefit coordination.
  6. Administrative Burden: Managing two dental insurance plans comes with a significant administrative burden. It can be difficult and time-consuming to file claims to two different insurers, track what is covered by which plan, and ensure that your providers are billing the appropriate insurance. Recall that every time you use your dental benefits, there is an additional step because the secondary plan usually requires the primary to provide an explanation of benefits prior to payout.
  7. Uncertainty Regarding Benefits Coordination: Distinct insurance providers may employ different strategies to manage benefits, which may cause uncertainty regarding the submission of claims and the extent of reimbursement. It takes careful management to know which services are covered first by the primary insurance and how the secondary insurance will contribute; improper handling of this information may lead to claim denials.
  8. Waiting Periods May Still Applicate: You might still have to wait before receiving full coverage for certain treatments if either of the dental insurance plans has a waiting period. The ability to receive more immediate care is delayed even with two policies, as the waiting period specified in the plan terms for services such as orthodontics or major restorations must be adhered to.
  9. Risk of Insurance Overlap and Policy Restrictions: When two policies are in place, it can be difficult to maximize benefits without going against the terms of either policy. Misunderstandings can also occur. There may be provisions that restrict the combination of benefits or provide complex guidelines for utilizing the benefits. Furthermore, if you don’t follow up with both insurers, you run the risk of coverage lapses or claim denials because of apparent discrepancies.
  10. Expense Increases and Financial Consequences: It is important to note that paying for two insurance policies entails paying two premiums. The extra expense may not result in benefits that are commensurate with one’s dental needs and coverage level. To make matters worse, every plan has the potential to have a deductible. If your secondary insurance does not cover this expense, you might have to pay more out of pocket than you had predicted. Therefore, in order to ascertain whether the benefits of dual coverage exceed its financial implications, a cost-benefit analysis is essential.
  11. Restrictive Plan Provisions: When combined with dual coverage, certain dental insurance policies contain provisions that become more restrictive. For example, non-duplication of benefits clauses specify that, up to the service cost, the secondary insurance will only cover the amount over what the primary insurance has paid. This may reduce the secondary insurance’s payout and have an impact on your total savings.
  12. Benefit Duplication and Needless Extra Expense: Having two dental insurance plans may result in you paying for benefits that overlap. The second plan might not offer extra value in line with its price if they both cover the same procedures in a comparable way and to the same degree. It’s possible that you’ll pay two premiums for coverage that isn’t all that superior to what one plan might have provided on its own.
  13. Increased Deductible Accumulation: It’s important to remember that having two insurances may result in paying less for services, but it may also mean that you have to meet two different deductibles before your insurance benefits kick in. This can be particularly difficult at the start of the policy year or when transferring to a different dental insurance company.

Having two dental insurance Making an Informed Decision

A person’s personal circumstances, dental health requirements and financial status should all be taken into consideration when deciding whether to pursue two dental insurance policies. It’s critical to carefully weigh the benefits and drawbacks, taking into account things like the extent of dental care required, the features provided by each plan, and the possibility of overlapping coverage or higher premiums. Making an informed choice can be aided by speaking with a financial advisor or dental insurance representative, who can offer insightful information.

Understanding Coordination of Benefits (COB) for two Dental Insurance

It is crucial to comprehend the idea of coordination of benefits (COB) when working with two dental insurance plans. The COB is a collection of guidelines that establishes how different insurance plans will cover identical medical or dental costs. COB aims to stop people from keeping more than 100% of the permitted fees for a service that is covered.

COB usually entails determining the primary and secondary plans when there are two dental insurance plans. The initial installment of the allowable charges must be covered by the primary plan. The secondary plan may take over to pay any costs that remain after the primary plan has paid its share, up to the policy maximums.

The specific COB rules for two dental insurance vary depending on the plans involved. However, some general principles apply:

  • Plan Order: Unless a primary plan is specifically designated, the primary plan is typically the one that the individual has had for the longest.
  • Up to its benefit caps, the primary plan will make payments first. The secondary plan may cover any costs up to its own benefit limits after the primary plan has made its payment.
  • Excess of Loss: The difference between the total allowable charges and the amount paid by the primary plan is known as the “excess of loss,” and in certain situations, the secondary plan may cover it.
  • Benefit Restrictions: Annual maximums and copayments are just two examples of the benefit restrictions that apply to each plan. These restrictions will still be in effect even if you have dual coverage.

Dealing with COB for two Dental Insurance

To ensure that claims are processed correctly under dual dental insurance, individuals should follow these steps:

  • Give Insurance Information: Give the dental office the primary and secondary insurance information when making an appointment.
  • Obtain Preauthorization: Before beginning treatment, get preauthorization from both insurance plans if the dental procedure is anticipated to be expensive.
  • File Claims: File claims with both insurance plans, even in the event that you anticipate having some of the costs paid by the secondary plan.
  • Examine Explanation of Benefits (EOB) Statements: Make sure there are no mistakes or inconsistencies and that the benefits have been applied correctly by carefully going over the EOBs from both plans.
  • Handle Billing Issues: To address any billing issues, get in quick contact with the relevant insurance plans.

Additional Considerations for two Dental Insurance

  • Preventive Care: More extensive coverage for preventive care, such as regular cleanings and exams, may be offered by dual dental insurance. By doing this, you may be able to keep your teeth healthy and possibly avoid the need for future, more costly treatments.
  • Dependent Coverage: It’s critical to comprehend how COB affects your dependents’ coverage if you have two dental insurance plans. Benefits may be arranged differently for each dependent, who may be regarded as a separate insured.
  • Changing Plans: It’s important to update your beneficiary information and notify both plans as soon as possible if your employment or personal circumstances change in a way that affects your dental insurance coverage.
  • Regular Review: Make sure you are getting the most out of the benefits and that your two dental insurance plans still suit your needs by reviewing them on a regular basis.

Is it illegal to have two dental insurance?

Having two dental insurance plans is not against the law. As a matter of fact, it is fairly typical, particularly for those who are married and both of their spouses have dental insurance. The terms “dual coverage” and “coordination of benefits” (COB) refer to the combination of two dental insurance plans.

Your dental insurance plans will cooperate to cover the cost of your dental care when you have dual coverage. The primary plan will be the one in which you are enrolled as the principal policyholder or as an employee. The secondary plan would be the one in which you are enrolled as a dependent.

Your dental care will be covered by your primary plan first, to the extent permitted by your policy. The secondary plan may cover part of the remaining expenses if there are any. The combined coverage from the two plans will not, however, go above 100% of the total costs.

There are a few things to keep in mind if you have dual coverage:

  • Ensure that your dental insurance plans are aware of any additional coverage you may have. This will assist them in arranging benefits and guaranteeing that you are not paying too much for your dental care.
  • Know the COB provisions of your plan. These clauses will specify how your plans will coordinate to cover the cost of your dental care.
  • Maintain a record of your dental costs. By doing this, you’ll be able to avoid any unpleasant surprises when your bills arrive.
  • In general, having two lines of coverage can be advantageous. In addition to ensuring you have the necessary coverage, it can help you save money on your dental care. To prevent any issues, it is crucial to understand how your plans function together.

Can you use two dental insurances for braces?

It is possible to use two dental insurance plans for braces, but it is more complicated than using one. The two dental insurance companies will collaborate to decide which plan will be the primary payer and which will be the secondary payer when you have dual dental coverage. The secondary plan will cover any remaining expenses up to the full cost of the treatment after the primary plan has paid its benefits.

There are a few things to keep in mind when using two dental insurances for braces:

  • Coordination of benefits (COB): This procedure establishes which plan will function as the primary payer and which as the secondary payer. COB is determined by several elements, such as the plan type, the age of the subscriber, and the enrollment date.
  • Maximum coverage limits: The maximum amount that most dental plans will pay for orthodontic treatment is limited. This implies that the insurance companies’ maximum amount of money that they will cover for braces is constrained. Should you surpass your maximum coverage limit, the remaining expenses must be covered entirely by you.
  • Waiting periods: Before receiving orthodontic treatment, some dental plans impose waiting periods. This implies that before the insurance company begins to pay for braces, you will need to wait a specific period of time. The primary and secondary plans may have different waiting periods.
Pros and cons of having two dental insurance
Pros and cons of having two dental insurance

It’s crucial to find out how benefits will be coordinated with your dental insurance companies before getting braces. This will assist you in avoiding any future surprises.

Here are some additional tips for using two dental insurances for braces:

  • Ensure that your insurance providers are informed: Ensure that your orthodontic treatment plan is disclosed to your insurance providers. This will facilitate their accurate processing of your claims.
  • Send in claims as soon as possible: As soon as you receive treatment, submit your claims to your insurance providers. This will assist in preventing any payment delays.
  • Maintain copies of all documents: Save copies of all the documents pertaining to your orthodontic care, such as invoices, bills, and insurance claims. If you have any queries or disagreements with your insurance providers, this will be beneficial.

Pros and cons of having two dental insurance in texas

Here’s a summary of the pros and cons of having two dental insurance plans in Texas:

Pros of having two Dental Insurance in texas:

  • Improved benefits and coverage: Having two dental insurance plans can give you more extensive coverage for various dental procedures, such as crowns, fillings, orthodontics, and preventive care. If you need extensive dental work or have a chronic dental condition, this can be especially helpful.
  • Diminished out-of-pocket expenses: You might be able to lower your out-of-pocket dental care expenses if you have two dental insurance plans. This is due to the possibility that the two plans will split the cost of your care, possibly paying for all of the associated costs.
  • Access to a larger dentist network: You may be limited in your provider options by certain dental insurance plans’ small networks of dentists. Possessing two plans can help you connect with a wider range of dentists, improving your chances of locating a dentist who is both convenient and skilled.

Cons of having two dental insurance in texas:

  • Added complexity: Compared to managing just one dental insurance plan, managing two can be more complicated. It can be complicated and time-consuming to keep track of various coverage levels, deductibles, and co-pays.
  • Possibility of higher premiums: If you have two dental insurance plans, your total premiums could go up, particularly if your plans’ coverage overlaps. When determining whether having dual coverage is worth the expense, it’s critical to carefully weigh the costs of the two plans.
  • Problems with coordination of benefits (COB): If you have two dental insurance plans, the COB procedure establishes which plan pays first and which plan pays second. There is a chance that disagreements between the insurance companies will result from this unclear process.
  • Not always required: A single dental insurance plan is adequate for the dental needs of a large number of people. It might not be necessary to have two plans if your mouth is generally in good health and you don’t need extensive dental care.

Additional considerations:

  • Your particular requirements: Consider the benefits and drawbacks of owning two dental insurance policies in light of your unique requirements and dental background. Dual coverage might be advantageous if you need frequent dental care or have a chronic dental condition.
  • Plans comparison: Before choosing to add a second dental insurance plan, carefully review the details of the first one. Think about the extent of coverage, co-pays, deductibles, and any restrictions or exclusions.
  • Consultation with a dentist: Talk to your dentist about your insurance options and dental care requirements. They can offer advice on whether having dual coverage makes sense for your particular circumstances.
  • Examining insurance documents: Pay close attention to the details of coverage, exclusions, and benefits coordination in the policy documents of the two dental insurance plans.

In conclusion, your unique situation and dental requirements will determine whether you should have two dental insurance plans in Texas. To make an informed choice, carefully consider the advantages and disadvantages, compare plans in-depth, and speak with your dentist.

How to calculate dual dental insurance copay?

It can be a little challenging to calculate your dual dental insurance copay because it requires knowledge of how the two insurance policies interact. But it’s not as hard as it sounds, once you know a little about it.

What is a copay?

A copay is a set amount that your dental insurance plan requires you to pay for each covered procedure. If your copay for a dental cleaning is $20, for instance, you would have to pay that amount each time, regardless of how much the treatment ends up costing.

How do dual dental insurance plans work?

If you have two dental insurance plans, approved services must be paid for first by the primary plan. Any further qualified costs will then be covered by the secondary plan, up to the plan’s maximum.

How to calculate your dual dental insurance copay?

Here is a general overview of how to calculate your dual dental insurance copay:

  • Establish the procedure’s acceptable charges. This is the sum that the insurance provider deems to be the procedure’s reasonable cost.
  • To the permitted expenses, apply the copay percentage of the primary insurance plan. This will show you how much the operation will cost covered by the primary plan.
  • Deduct the payment for the primary plan from the authorized charges. You will then be able to see the remaining allowable costs.
  • Apply the copay percentage of the secondary insurance plan to the remaining allowable costs. This will show you how much the procedure will cost covered under the secondary plan.

Deduct the payment from the secondary plan from the remaining allowable costs. This represents the total amount you will have to pay for the procedure, or your out-of-pocket price.Here is an example of how to calculate your dual dental insurance copay:

  • Procedure: Dental cleaning
  • Allowable charges: $100
  • Primary insurance plan: 80% copay, $200 maximum coverage per procedure
  • Secondary insurance plan: 50% copay, $100 maximum coverage per procedure
Pros and cons of having two dental insurance
Pros and cons of having two dental insurance
  • Primary insurance payment: $100 x 80% = $80
  • Remaining eligible expenses: $100 – $80 = $20
  • Secondary insurance payment: $20 x 50% = $10
  • Out-of-pocket expense: $20 – $10 = $10

In this example, your total out-of-pocket expense for the dental cleaning would be $10.

Additional factors to consider

There are a few additional factors that can affect your dual dental insurance copay, such as:

  • Deductibles: The amount you have to pay out-of-pocket before your dental insurance company begins to pay for approved services is known as the deductible in some plans.
  • Maximum coverage: The maximum amount that the insurance company will pay for eligible procedures in a given year is known as the maximum coverage limit, and it is a feature of the majority of dental insurance plans.

The concept of coordination of benefits (COB) establishes the primary and secondary insurance plans. Depending on the insurance company involved, these regulations may change.

You should speak with your insurance company to find out more information if you have any issues concerning the copay for your dual dentistry insurance.


Potential advantages of having two dental insurance plans include better coverage, lower out-of-pocket expenses and a larger provider network. It’s crucial to carefully consider these benefits in light of any potential disadvantages, including as higher premiums, the possibility of overlapping coverage, and additional administrative complexity. People can efficiently negotiate dual dental insurance and maximize their benefits by being aware of COB regulations, giving proper insurance information and being proactive in resolving any billing concerns.

  1. Can I have 3 dental insurance plans?

    Yes, you can have multiple dental insurance plans. This is called “stacking” your insurance. However, there are a few things you should keep in mind before doing so:

    Benefits coordination: If you have several insurance policies, the insurance providers will collaborate to decide which plan will pay out first, second, and so forth. Benefits coordination is what we call this. The amount you owe out of pocket may vary depending on the sequence in which the plans pay.

    Maximum coverage limits: The most that an insurance plan will pay for approved services in a given year is known as the maximum coverage limit. This limit varies from plan to plan. Should you use up all of your coverage on a single plan, you will be responsible for covering the cost of any additional treatments yourself.

    Coinsurance and deductibles: These are additional features of every insurance plan. The amount you must pay out-of-pocket before the insurance company begins to reimburse you is known as the deductible. The portion of the cost of covered treatments that you are required to pay after meeting the deductible is known as the coinsurance.

    Stacking dental insurance coverage is generally not a good idea unless you have a significant risk of dental issues or a big dental price burden. This is due to the likelihood that your premium payments will exceed the savings on out-of-pocket expenses.

    Speak with your insurance agent to see whether stacking dental insurance coverage is a smart option for you if you're thinking about doing so. They can assist you in comprehending your plans' coinsurance, deductibles, maximum coverage limits, and benefit coordination. Additionally, they can assist you in determining which plan should pay out first and which plan should pay out second.

    Here are three examples of dental insurance plans:

    Delta Dental PPO: Members of this plan can take advantage of a network of dentists who have committed to offering members lower prices. Although it will cost extra, you have the option to see a dentist who is not in your network.

    Cigna Dental 1500: This plan offers a reduced maximum coverage limit along with a monthly cost that is less than that of the Delta Dental PPO plan. Although it will cost extra, you have the option to see a dentist who is not in your network.

    Aetna Dental HMO: Under this plan, you will have to select a primary care dentist to handle all of your dental needs. A dentist cannot be seen outside of your network.

    There are numerous different dental insurance plans available; these are just a few examples. To select the plan that is best for you, thoroughly analyze the available options.

  2. What is the best insurance to have for dental?

    The best dental insurance for you will depend on your individual needs and circumstances. However, some of the top-rated dental insurance companies include:

    Cigna: Cigna offers dental insurance that includes preventative treatment without any deductibles or copays, and it has a large network of more than 89,000 dentists available at more than 300,000 sites around the country.
    With a network of more than 150,000 dentists, Delta Dental is the biggest dental insurance provider in the US. There are several different plans available from Delta Dental, including ones that don't require waiting periods for routine care.

    Guardian: Though it is a smaller dental insurance provider, Guardian is known for its top-notch customer support. There are numerous plans available from Guardian, some of which do not have annual maximums.

    Humana: Dental insurance is provided by Humana, a sizable health insurance provider. Humana's dental policies are renowned for their extensive coverage and reasonable prices.

    Spirit Dental: Spirit Dental is a dental insurance provider that provides plans without deductibles or waiting periods for preventive services. Additionally, Spirit Dental has a network of over 15,000 dentists.

Faisal Ahmed

Hey! I'm Faisal Ahmed, the author of Tips Degree. I have a strong desire to educate people about education, science and technology, finance, and other trending topics through my content that's easy to understand. These contents created by me have helped many trainees around the world grow their careers. In my spare time, I love to swim and watch movies. I'm available on social media sites like Facebook, Pinterest, Medium, Flickr, etc.

Related Articles

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Back to top button